I’ve been trying to apply the mantra Keep It Simple Stupid to my sermons since returning to the pulpit. I don’t know if it has improved my preaching but I plan on continuing to focus on simplicity.
You see, the big temptation I have is to try to be creative or put a new spin on a text, or look at it from a fresh perspective. This is understandable, given that sermons (especially following the lectionary) can get as repetitive, boring and stale to preach as they can be to listen to. So I find myself tempted to makes something more interesting by developing a more complicated sermon structure or approaching a text from a less obvious way, looking at inferences or subplots rather than the main point. The problem is that complexity makes a sermon more difficult to follow and the less obvious bits I seem to pick up on can tend to also be less important; there’s a reason the main point of the text is the main point.
So I’ve committed myself of a year of preaching the most basic, simple and obvious message of each Sunday’s text in order to serve the meat and potatoes instead of intellectual delicacies and creative, theological tidbits. As I do so I find myself pushed to make things more interesting by focusing more on presentation, illustration and clarity.
This seems like an obvious thing to do, but when you come to a story for the 10th year in a row the first question seems to be, ‘How can I deal with this that isn’t just like what I’ve done the past three times’ rather than ‘What does this say to us, here and now?’
Certainly having a clear and consise message can be helpful and you must always consider your audience. However, you should be careful not to miss out on the opportunity to grow as a presenter and also to help your audience grow and understand things in new ways. It’s a fine line to walk and I think you do an excellent job (granted, I haven’t been around much recently). Maybe consider using your blog (or a podcast type deal) for expanding on simplified ideas in your sermons. This might also be a good way to keep people engaged in the message longer which would allow for further growth and development of ideas.